✓ Six months of executive coaching with every leadership placement   ✓ 22 years recruiting across healthcare in Canada & the US
Leadership That Stays · Episode · March 17, 2026

Global Physician Leadership with Dr. Giuseppe Guaiana

Kevin Kirkpatrick interviews Dr. Giuseppe Guaiana, Chief of Psychiatry at St. Thomas Elgin General Hospital. They discuss his career journey in physician leadership, the challenges he faced transitioning from clinical practice to leadership roles, and the importance of mentorship and support systems. The conversation also touches on the impact of technology in mental health care, the significance of continuous learning in leadership, and the need for effective resource allocation in healthcare systems.

Watch

Listen

25:04 · Leadership That Stays with Kevin Kirkpatrick

Takeaways

  • System thinking is important in healthcare leadership.
  • Efficiency and compassion are two sides of the same coin.
  • Mentorship played a crucial role in his career development.
  • New leaders should not be afraid to ask for help.
  • Support from peers and administration is vital for effective leadership.
  • The allocation of resources in healthcare is a significant challenge.
  • Technology is increasingly being integrated into mental health services.
  • Continuous learning matters in leadership roles.
  • Building good relationships with peers is essential for leadership success.

In their words

“It’s okay not to know everything.”
“The allocation of resources is key.”

About this episode

Leadership That Stays is a healthcare leadership podcast hosted by Kevin Kirkpatrick, founder of Avery Professional Group. It features conversations with healthcare CEOs, executives, physician leaders and industry experts about building a leadership team that can succeed and stay. Topics include executive recruitment, succession planning, culture, physician engagement, workforce retention, onboarding and leadership development.

Hiring or developing a physician leader? See Physician Executive Search, our Executive Search and Strategy Consulting.

Transcript

Read the full transcript

Auto-generated transcript, lightly formatted. It may contain errors.

Welcome to Physicians Who Lead, the podcast, where we sit down with physician leaders who are shaping the future of healthcare. Each episode we dive into the real challenges facing our system today and hear directly from the physicians leading the way with innovation, resilience, and vision. If you want to understand how Healthcare is changing and meet the leaders driving that change, you’re in the right place. Welcome to the Physician Who Lead podcast. My name is Kevin Kirkpatrick. I’m the CEO of the Avery Professor Group. Today, my guest is Doctor Gianna and we are going to talk about his career in physician leadership. Welcome to the podcast. Thank you very much and for having me. Very happy to be here. My pleasure. Now, I will admit you’re the first psychiatrist and leader that I’ve had.

All right, interesting. Yeah, so currently I’m Chief of psychiatry at Saint Thomas Elgin General Hospital, so we can have a medium sized Community Hospital and also I also directed the satellite services in Northern Ontario for Western University called the extended campus program. So we do outreach mental health services to the northern communities in the east of Thunder Bay. So I’ve actually the director, I’ve been actually doing these two jobs for a long time, more than a decade. So the Saint Thomas Elgin General Hospital, I’ve been appointed as leader in 2012 before actually the program was starting, actually helped to plan the program, start the program and that was a manager at the time. So together we work on that and also the North Superior wars, the Northern Ontario work. I’ve been doing that for almost 14 years now.

Again, as a leader, we’re kind of a small group of four psychiatrists provided providing actually services in the north. So it’s been a long journey, the very difficult to beginning, but it’s becoming more and more enjoyable, more and more comfortable. I have to say yeah. What’s the the Saint Thomas program? What? What’s the mental health program like at the hospital? Yes. So it is a mental problem including inpatient unit who have a 15 bed inpatient unit and also outpatient program with a few counselors, occupational therapy, social workers, nurses and there is also a behavioral support on there, which is the dementia condom more behavioral problem that is also associated with our with our it’s a full program catering to people with the intermediately severe mental health problems. Excellent.

And then what type of for the Northern Ontario, what type and I assume that’s that’s delivered virtually, what type of services do you provide for mental health? Yeah. So we provide mostly outpatient service to about 5 to 6 communities in the east of Thunder Bay. So we are partnering with an organization they are local counseling organization called the North Superior Counseling Program and we provide the adult psychiatry services there. So we it is in in an outpatient outpatient program provide mostly deliver virtual, but I travel being the director and I say it’s nice to kind of travel and see the community have been doing that for almost yeah, even before I was it was a leader that since 2011. And so I travel twice a year and that’s why I deliver care in person. But we do mostly virtual by by video, mostly exclusively outpatient because of course we cannot see inpatient from from a far obviously.

As the as the medical director from for Psychiatry, what got you into wanting to be in a leadership role? I like systems so very kind of very kind of system think and I like the idea that if you make a system, however small or big, if you make it efficient to help no more not not one person, but maybe an entire population population of 30 thousand 40,000 millions. It depends on on how big the system is. So I like the idea of making the system work, making more efficient, because I feel that really efficiency and compassion are kind of two sides of the same coin, so to speak. Is the idea that if I make a service efficient, really I can provide really being more compassion because I can provide good service and the services are very, very, very fast and very, very, very efficient. Also, I like the idea of creating good working environments.

So that’s also what led me to become a leader. It’s one of, I would say the main, the main, one of the main reasons, in addition to the system, the idea that it’s nice to have a very relaxed, good working environment where everybody’s respect, everybody’s valued. And that’s what I really strive for on in my day-to-day practice. That’s that’s really what drew me into into leadership, the idea of I can really have some control over that environment. When it came to transitioning from purely clinical to leadership, did you take any specific courses or were there any mentorship or anything like that that helped you make that transition? So I took several courses and all throughout of at the beginning it was, it was called the PLI, the physician leadership courses. So start in 2013. So these are course organized by the Canada Medical Association.

So at that time was a physician leadership issues. Now I don’t remember probably changed name, but this course that are kind of very different topic like negotiation, any management, how to self lead, how to self-care about 5 courses and and then all over my training. I always can’t kind of continue doing courses. The last one was the OMA at Rothman Institute course organized by the OMA and the Rothman Institute in the University of Toronto that I finished last year. It’s always nice to and continue revising and continue learning in the leadership journey. Nice. Yeah, one of the things that we talk a lot about is, you know, is mentorship and coaches and support and stuff like that. Can you think of somebody that’s been a mentor to you during your career? Yes, several people. First of all, it was one of the of my first, my first actually boss when I moved to Canada.

I moved to Canada in 2009, 2009 in my at the Times Doctor Rami Rodnick was a was a great, great mentor to me. He kind of gave me really some good advice. He was actually the director, for example, of the Norton Ontario program before me. So he gave me all the advice manager to clinic and also give him lots of opportunity in about to now I’m in contact with with him. He moved to Nova Scotia, but he gave me also, for example, an opportunity to become associate editor for the Canadian Journal of a physician leader at the rural leadership section. So it’s been, it’s a person that I really appreciate and really enjoyed actually working. I enjoyed working with, enjoy being contact with. Where did you relocate from? From Switzerland, I was living in Switzerland. I’m originally Italian, so I work in Italy.

Then I moved to the United Kingdom for about four years and to Switzerland for four years and then the last since 2009. So that’s almost 17 years I’ve been living in Canada. My my daughter did a European vacation her last year of high school and Switzerland. Interesting. They spent there wasn’t a long amount of time. I think it might have been a day and 1/2. All right then. Switzerland, But she just fell in love with it, right? So she’s already planning on how to, yes, leave up and visit them. Yeah, right. Definitely, definitely. Then it’s Italy is an it’s an interesting time with the Olympics. Yeah, absolutely. And they are in my hometown. I’m from Milan actually, so they’re actually my hometown. So definitely the enjoyable. Absolutely. Good to know and. They’re leading. I think they’re leading the metal.

Yeah, I think so, yeah. Yeah, I think so, yeah. Yeah. So Italy is pretty good with the winter sports. Not much hockey, unfortunately, it’s not very, but other winter for skiing etcetera. They’re very, very, very, very strong. It’s interesting how leadership ties into sports. Absolute stuff. Like that too, right? Like it’s. Yeah, it’s an interesting cross section. What is the biggest challenge that you faced moving into a leadership role? So at the very beginning was really learning the role. That was very difficult. I had mentor, but really I had to do the day-to-day work. I had to kind of make the decisions, understand the system. My particular challenge was also the program was new. There was number that we had to invent the program from scratch. There was number previous chief, no previous director.

So that was very, very difficult. And so that was the challenge in making decision, dealing with new problems on a daily basis. At the very beginning that was extremely, extremely difficult. But then slowly it took me a long time to kind of be comfortable, maybe four or five years, even longer to start it becoming really more comfortable in in the leadership position. If you could go back and give yourself some advice at the start of your leadership journey, what advice would you give yourself? My person, it was don’t worry too much. In reality, at some point we’re going to learn the the tricks of the trade. It may take longer. Inside the old school, I would probably ask for help. So that would say ask for help. Don’t be afraid to say that you don’t know because sometimes it was very difficult for me because I, I thought I too knew everything.

And in reality, it’s OK not to know everything and to be, particularly in new programs, I would say don’t worry too much and ask for help would be the two major pieces of advice that will give to people. To myself, I mean, yeah. And we, and we often hear through the podcast and we, I often hear through the podcast, you know, sometimes how the role that you’re stepping into is not completely defined. And in your case with there being no program, that’s that’s definitely the case. And then the second thing I hear about, and I think this is a differentiator between good hospitals and bad is the support you get from from your your peers and from your administration and stuff like that, right? Do you do you feel well supported and how do you build a good relationship? Yes. So our hospital as I have to say tradition of approachable leadership and good environment.

Normally I don’t last ten years in a place if I don’t like. So it’s kind of I vote with my feet in a way. I’ve been in this hospital for 12 even more 1213 years. So that so I can I have a regular reach out with the VP for one of the VPS, for example, my chief of staff. So I reported chief of staff regular reach out. And so I feel extremely well supported and even the CEO, it’s very approachable. I can e-mail her, knock at her door talk in case there is so there is no ivory, ivory tower Ishkando attitude in the in the administration. It’s always very, very, very well supported. Even also working not only in the kind of app also parallel with the managers in the school leadership that we have. It has not always been easy depending on the the last manager we have is extremely good. We worked well together and it’s very important.

It’s very important that because what I find with our message, they get the clinical picture. It’s not only metric, it’s not only they understand the problem we face as physician, the difficult patients that the difficulties in general, they get it and that’s why they support us. And it’s, I think that’s key, right, is understanding, understanding how to support the role beyond metrics and other aspects of it as well, right? So yeah, I think that’s interesting. What do you think is the biggest challenge being a physician leader? It is actually the situation that you cannot control. So it’s the the the environment. So the number of referral, for example, number of mental illness problems that so things that it and also that the system around us because of course our health system is not perfect, not at all.

And there are difficulties for example, in transferring patient to more tertiary care organization for example, or relation with external organizations that that’s kind of the challenge we face more external challenges, I have to say. So from the environment or for the other programs to us and also for example, the number, the referrals we receive. But we are, we are kind of managing that now. We’re starting managing that pretty well, yeah. Well, it’s in mental health is a is a challenge. There’s just a shortage of psychiatrists in general, yeah. That’s yeah, that’s a good point, the shortest. But also I have to say sometimes there is the results, there is a absolute shortage, but also relative shortage. So for example, one, one example is there’s one very important study published in 2014 showing that for example in Toronto percentage of psychiatrist on population is very high.

So there’s a lot of psychiatrist there in Toronto. While as you go outside the Toronto, even Mississauga, for example, and if you go to London, the shortage is, is more pronounced. The other thing is also not every every case I need to be seen as psychiatrist. So there is also sometimes we need to kind of raise the awareness and sometimes not all psychiatrist, not everybody mental problems to see psychiatrist. Maybe there are other avenues from family medicine to other counselors to other organization that can also help so we can kind of focus on the one that are more severe and require really intense, intense follow up and intense input. Yeah, because it’s, it’s an interesting scenario, right? Because you, you know, there’s, there’s different resources depending on the size of the community, right?

Yeah, I recruit physicians across a lot of. Different, right And. You know, in Ontario or in, in the GTA, sorry, there are lots of communities where the family physicians are looking for more patients. Yeah, because we’ve had an influx of coming from other parts of the world, whether it be the US or UK and setting up in Toronto, because, you know, that’s where most people, if you, if you’re coming a lot, you know, it’s the preferred destination. But then if you go 2 hours outside, then the shortage is definitely there, right. And I think one of the hardest things is the allocation of resources across the geography. Absolutely. That’s why, for example, there is a outreach program, the program I lead for Northern Ontario. We are not in Northern Ontario, we are in Southern Ontario and and we travel up north.

Absolutely the location, resources is, is key. And sometimes they’re they’re not for whatever reason, right. The some people don’t like to move to northern areas of people outside of Toronto. Everybody wants to be in Toronto, understandably say it’s a vibrant city, but it will be nice to kind of explore also the possibility that is not necessarily outside of Toronto that can be also good work. They can do both clinically or lifestyles or in general. That’s also that’s one of the issue from the week as a leader. We cannot control where people live. They the right to live to live wherever they want and is the strong preference is to live in Toronto and and the family daughter want to relocate only to Toronto. That’s that’s something we have to understand and maybe see whether we can attract people in a in a different way to, to commit to the smaller than than the big cities.

Yeah, well, I think technology helps that a lot. Right. Yes, of course. The the OTN and now through different platforms, you know, the ability to deliver mental health services virtually is quite, quite better off than it than it was. The other thing, and I mean I don’t ask all leaders this, but you’re in a bit of a special scenario, is that I use an app called Living and it’s, I consider it more of a meditation app type of thing, but it is a mental health based app that uses AI to communicate with you through chat and stuff like that. Do you see a prevalence of those types of things within the mental health landscape? Yes, people are using my app more and more. As you all know very well, Chachi PT is, for example, one of the mental health kind of counselor that so more and more people and I’m seeing more and more that are using that, although the the return is still early days.

So it’s very difficult to assess its impact, whether it’s positive or negative. We hear a lot of kind of negative impact. While such GPTS, for example, or or some AI up may may not deliver the product and that may not deliver, you know, what they promised. And the main thing is as many, many up and and it’s very difficult to assess up on, on their merit. I wish there was maybe some more research. There are there are some researchers publishing more and more on what apps and using AI are useful and what are what apps are less useful. So it’s still, I would say it’s all open. The judgment is open for now. Yeah, the state of Illinois actually put in legislation that AI could not be used without clinician guidance. Yeah, that’s a good point. For now, I think it’s wise. And I think that there’s something to be said for that.

You mean this app that I use is very superficial? Right. And I talked to it mostly about business things, to be honest with you, and a bit of anxiety. But I would never intend tend to replace a, a licensed clinician, whether it be a psychologist or psychiatrist with a, with an app. That’s just my, you know, But you know, knowing that you can’t see your psychiatrist every day, having this sort of meditational type of app, I found quite, quite helpful. Yeah, definitely, definitely. I think the combination of of I like, I like the Illinois submelion approach because the combination of clinician and up, that’s probably what this winning combination because you can use up that the clinician has vetted for example, that maybe clinician knows. So it’s very good. It’s a very good way. And probably that’s why we should use apps and and AI as of now, yeah.

Well, it’s, it’s interesting because I think there’s a lot of different factors with respect to what, you know, what, what makes the clinician successful, right. I, I had a psychiatrist that was quite experienced that I really enjoyed and had a great relationship. When she retired, the younger psychiatrist and I just We didn’t gel. Right, right. Right, because you mean just for the sake of just not a fit in the same fit, right? Yeah, yeah. So there’s aspects of that, but now that I’ve gone on a sidetrack, so I apologize for that. But when it comes to, you know, being a leader because you know, in a medical director’s in Ontario, you’re, you’re still, you’ve still got a clinical workload as well as. Creative. How do you manage going from being the A peer to then being the leader of your peers as the medical director?

Well, that hasn’t been in my case very, very complicated because with the program being started from scratch in my, so I recruited, I was already a leader was the kind of the first guys being recruited and and then everything start, I started as a leader. So it was it was easier then. It’s very easy, very easy. And I know it’s been difficult for some people, but for example, I can say from somebody who was my peer and became my leader and my current chief of staff was my peer and now became a leader. But it has, it has been good because the main, the main, the main issue that we, we respect each other. If there isn’t respect, we are really on the same page. In many cases. We have the same goal. So that’s, that’s been the important. So that hasn’t been as disruptive or as, as, as bad as, as I was thinking, right?

Because maybe there’s the peer that becoming that’s becoming your your boss who don’t know what what’s happening, but. Definitely has been working pretty well. What kind of the last question I have for you is how do you keep yourself up to date on leadership information and leadership trends? I mean, obviously on the clinical side, you’ve got your Cmes and stuff. Yes, Sir. How do you keep How do you keep up to date on leadership tactics? So it mostly courses as of now. So I do, I’ve been doing courses all over my leadership career from what the course I was mentioned to the last course I’ve attended. So that’s what’s the main, the main thing. I do that periodically every every few years. So I get kind of like I load on information then then actually metabolize information for a few years, then see what’s what’s on there.

Then also there is a very good association which is Canadian Association of Physician Leaders. They actually do also a very rigorous certification when you can become a Canadian certified physician executive. So I have that certification that helped me kind of can in understanding my leadership style. So help me a lot. So there’s a conference, so a annual conference and again, I attend the conference on a regular basis. So I keep me that keep me up today. So that’s the main, the main thing. And then there’s the Journal also the Canadian physician leader that they have, they’re also the the side podcast for that association. So I tried to use couple of sources at the most for my update. It’s interesting. I talked to, I had a guest on the podcast last week or we recorded it last week. It hasn’t gone live yet, but he had written a book and worked with the AGME in the US to actually create a a credentialed leadership course under the same organization that looks at their medical education.

Yeah, interesting. Yeah, so, so you mean it’s interesting. There’s, there’s a lot of different resources and I, yeah, thing I’m going to, I’m going to do it because I had a physician in BC reach out to me asking about leadership courses and I was able to compile a list of 5 or 6 different programs for the, this physician to look at. So I should create a resource on my website of different programs because, you know, even if it’s US, there’s still a value to it, you know, because the biggest difference is, is, is the financial side of things. But a lot of things are probably quite quite similar, right? Yeah, the leadership party to the style or for example the self management these courses or these kind of resources can be can be definitely the same. Also there are that Canadian Medical Association does some courses that are very very good and and well attended I think.

Yeah, there’s becoming more and more options within Canada. The chief of staff from Humber River when I was there, he teaches through Rotman. I think it is no Shulick. He teaches a leadership course through Shulick and, and stuff like that. It’s like a 10 month thing and they’re starting to pop up more and more, right? So I think that’s, I think that’s good. But I do the podcast because I want to talk to more leaders and encourage more, of course, to, to get into leadership and invest in them in leadership, because I think it goes a long way to helping organizations deal with changing trends and, and changing strategies and stuff like that. So it’s, you know, it’s quite interesting. Yeah, definitely more people we need desperately need good leadership. I thinking in Canada, but I would say everywhere, but definitely we need really trend people that think outside of the box and and can be creative because that’s definitely extreme important, yeah.

Yeah. And I think as we try and improve things like physician engagement, physician burnout and those different things, but the one way to do it is to invest more in our leaders, yeah, so that they can invest more in in the clinical staff to try and support them as well. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. I think it’s that, you know, teach the leaders and then let the leaders teach more, more people, right, or train the trainer, I think they call it in the corporate world. So, you know, it’s interesting from that standpoint. So I appreciate you taking the time to talk to me today. You know, I guess go Italy in the Olympics. Thank you very much. Hopefully, yeah. I don’t think they’re playing Canada in hockey. Yeah, exactly. I will feel conflated. Exactly. You can. Say go Italy in that case. But I appreciate you taking the time and I, I look forward to continuing to communicate with you and chat and thank you for coming on the podcast.

No problem. Thank you so much for having me. It was a great pleasure. Take care, bye.

More conversations

Leading a hospital or health organization?

Talk to Kevin

Tell me about the leadership seat or the retention problem you are working on.

Start a conversation